Brady Catanzarite is a forward who began his collegiate career at Ohio Wesleyan University in the fall of the 2025 season.

During his first season, Catanzarite appeared in 10 matches for the Battling Bishops.

Prior to college, he earned four varsity letters in soccer. His high school career at Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit was highlighted by All-America, All-Ohio, and All-Region honors, while helping to lead his team to a state runner-up finish. He also set school career records for assists and total points.

Catanzarite made his debut for Cleveland SC on June 28, 2025, against Niagara 1812, appearing in two matches during the 2025 season.