Noah Sandahl is a defender from Brook Park, Ohio, and a graduate of Berea-Midpark High School, where he was a three-year captain and standout performer. His high school career was highlighted by a 2023 All-State selection, 2022 All-Greater Cleveland honors, two All-Conference nods, and back-to-back team MVP awards.

In addition to his high school success, Noah competed with Spire Academy, helping the team qualify for the 2024 USYS National Tournament and the Midwest Regional events in both 2022 and 2023.

He continued his playing career at the University of Detroit Mercy, where he made 16 appearances with four starts as a freshman, followed by 14 appearances and six starts in his second season.

Noah made his Cleveland SC debut on June 15, 2025, against Flower City Union after missing the first part of the season due to injury. He made an immediate impact by assisting the match equalizer in a 3–3 draw and went on to appear in four matches, including two starts, while recording one assist during the 2025 season.