Match Report | Erie Commodores FC vs Cleveland SC

Faye Hat Trick Nearly Stuns Conference Champions as Cleveland SC Falls 4-3 to Erie

ERIE, PENNSYLVANIA – Cleveland SC's regular season came to a close on Saturday night in dramatic fashion, as the club pushed Great Lakes Conference champions Erie Commodores FC to the limit before ultimately falling 4-3 in one of the most entertaining matches of the season.

Despite the result, Cleveland left Erie with plenty to be proud of after delivering a performance that proved the club belongs among the conference's elite as the postseason approaches.

The opening stages of the match were evenly contested, with both teams trading possession and creating chances without either side fully taking control.

Cleveland and Erie each found success moving the ball into dangerous areas, but strong defensive play and timely interventions kept the match scoreless through the opening half hour.

The breakthrough finally came in the 33rd minute, and it was a goal worthy of winning any highlight reel.

Following a short corner routine, Erie delivered a cross into the penalty area where a header fell perfectly to Julian Tovar. The Erie attacker wasted no time, unleashing an incredible bicycle kick that flew past Alex Normandeau and into the back of the net to give the hosts a 1-0 lead.

The spectacular strike was one of the finest goals Cleveland has conceded all season and sent Erie into halftime with the advantage.

Things got worse for Cleveland shortly after the restart.

An unfortunate own goal in the 47th minute doubled Erie's lead and appeared to put the conference champions firmly in control of the match at 2-0.

Many teams would have folded against the top side in the Great Lakes Conference. Cleveland did the exact opposite.

Over the next eight minutes, Abdou Faye produced one of the most remarkable individual performances of the season.

The forward got Cleveland on the board in the 51st minute before striking again six minutes later to cut the deficit even further. Just two minutes after that, Faye completed a stunning hat trick in the 59th minute to turn a two-goal deficit into a 3-2 Cleveland lead.

Hakim Musabbah provided the assist on Faye's second goal, while Noah Sandahl set up the third as Cleveland completely flipped the match on its head.

The three-goal outburst stunned Erie and represented something few teams had managed to do all season.

During that ten-minute stretch, Cleveland forced Erie to concede more goals than they had allowed in any single match throughout the regular season. Against a defense that had been nearly impossible to break down for most opponents, Cleveland's attack produced a breathtaking display of quality and determination.

For a brief period, Cleveland looked poised to hand the conference champions one of their most memorable defeats of the year.

Faye's incredible evening came to an end in the 67th minute when he was substituted off after delivering one of the finest individual performances by a Cleveland player this season.

As the match entered its final stages, Erie showed exactly why it finished atop the conference standings.

The hosts continued to push forward and eventually found an equalizer in the 76th minute when Syrus Conolly found the back of the net to level the match at 3-3.

Both teams searched for a winner over the closing minutes, and Cleveland generated a few dangerous opportunities that ultimately failed to materialize.

Then came the decisive moment.

In the 89th minute, Dylan Sumner scored the winning goal for Erie, breaking Cleveland hearts and giving the conference champions a 4-3 advantage they would not surrender.

When the final whistle sounded, Cleveland was left disappointed to come away empty-handed after leading one of the conference's best teams late in the match.

Still, there is no reason for this group to hang its head.

While the result did not go Cleveland's way, the performance served as a reminder that this club is capable of competing with anyone in the Great Lakes Conference. Few teams pushed Erie as hard as Cleveland did on Saturday night, and the resilience shown after falling behind 2-0 should provide confidence heading into the postseason.

The focus now shifts to the playoffs.

The opening round of the Great Lakes Conference Playoffs begins on Wednesday, July 8, and Cleveland will use the upcoming break to prepare for what promises to be an exciting postseason run.

The most likely first-round opponent is Ambassadors FC Ohio, a team Cleveland defeated twice during the regular season, first by a 3-0 scoreline at George Finnie Stadium and later with a 2-0 victory on the road.

The playoff picture is still taking shape.

With the loss, Ambassadors currently hold second place in the conference based on points per game despite trailing Cleveland in total points. Ambassadors still have two matches remaining against Buffalo Stallions FC and Erie Commodores FC, meaning Cleveland will need some help if it hopes to host a playoff match.

Regardless of where the postseason begins, Cleveland has already accomplished something significant this year.

After missing the playoffs for the past two seasons, the club has re-established itself as one of the top teams in the Great Lakes Conference. With a talented roster, one of the league's best defenses, and the confidence gained from competing toe-to-toe with the conference champions, Cleveland enters the postseason believing a deep playoff run is well within reach.

The regular season may be over, but the most important soccer of the year is just beginning.

Stay Connected

Keep up with all the latest news and updates from Cleveland SC on our website and social media platforms: Facebook, X, Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube.